Is this game really on trouble?

So, I understand that this game hasn't be in a positive light in the eyes of a lot of players. There are already so many content creators talking about it on YouTube, but I am wondering if any of their thoughts are reasonable or just doom posting. Like, I understand that it is best to speak up your thoughts and give critic about a game, from anything you like to dislike about the game, but there has been so many negativity that it affects mentality not in a good way.

So what do you guys think? Do you think all of the negativity valid or reasonable or even annoying? Or do you think it is too gloomy doom posting and making too much of a big deal?