Barefoot Luxury?

Looking for an adults only, low-rise, tropical, laid back resort with good+ food. We don’t need fancy or activities or night life. We are late 50s and just want to relax. We’ve been going to the same place in Jamaica for 20+ years (easy and predictable), but we think it’s time to move on. Flying from ATL. 7 nights. Travel would be Nov/Dec or April. ~$2k/night would be the high end for this trip not including airfare.

I’ve looked at Hermitage Bay in Antigua. It’s a big budget jump from what we’ve been doing, but completely doable. The vibe seems to be just what we are looking for. Just wondering if it is worth it. Any other suggestions?