Would you sell mageblade for 1K?

Last night I was in a MC 2SR run where I won mageblade and got offered 1k by another mage. I immediately equipped it because my rationale is I can farm gold but I can't farm the p1/2 bis wep.

But this got me thinking, with edgies selling for ~1k which are bis until tbc, was this a fair offer? Would you have taken the 1k or would you have wanted more?