SPYI versus SCHD

I know SPYI and SCHD have come up a fair bit, but wondering what people think for a younger (26M) investor.

I maxed my Roth for 2024 and 2025 and currently 80% of my Roth is made up of VOO and ITOT, with smaller amounts in VT and VGT (I know there’s a ton of overlap - that’s not my concern. My preference is to be S&P500 heavy)

The remaining 20% is made up 10% SCHD, 5% SPYI and 5% SPAXX MM for just a small amount of cash reserve.

I am heavily inclined to move away from SCHD. From an overhead view of tracking my portfolio, it really isn’t doing much for me. While I appreciate that SCHD has less volatility on down days (even being in the green sometimes when the total market is red) and generally has little overlap with my other investments, for the year or so of me investing, it’s been pretty underwhelming.

I understand it’s only been 1 year - I also understand that SPYI is relatively new and riskier. Still, I really want to sell off my SCHD and drop it in SPYI. I love the 11-12% APY dividend yield, while also getting dividends each month. Even the stock price itself has grown.

For someone with a 30+ year horizon for my Roth where I don’t plan on withdrawing from until retirement (barring unexpected life events), is there any reason to choose SCHD as my dividend stock? I know one common answer would be dividend funds as a whole aren’t as strong as your typical growth fund with this horizon, but I like having some dividend growth - I like the prospect of it and I have a good time watching dividends hit my account.

Does anyone know of an app/site where I can compare the growth of SCHD and SPYI with dividends reinvested? I’d be curious to see how they compare since SPYIs inception