MFK Grand Soir / Kilians Angel Share

Hey guys, this is my second time buying clones. My first time i bought Lattafa Maahir Legacy as a clone of Sedley and I fell in love from how close it was. Now, 6 months later, I am looking to get a winter(y) scent and I am looking at both MFK Grand Soir and Kilians Angel Share. For MFK Grand Soir, I have heard of Naseem’s Paris Oud and Paris Corner’s North Stag Quatre 9. Apparently North Stag Quatre is closer, but I am not sure as I havent smelt it. For Angel’s Share, I am stuck between Sharaf blend and Royal Blend. I want to get the closest scents that last and project really well. What should I get?