I’m straight and my “straight” married friend (with 6 kids) asked me to fuck him.

My friend Jake is 31 and I’m 33. I met Jake at the gym 2 years ago through basketball.

Jake is married with his 6th kid on the way. I’m white, single, tall, just average musculature and Jake is black (but has light brown skin), short afro, muscular dad bod that looks good and big but not super defined. Shorter than me at 5’9” while I’m almost 6’4”.

We became good friends and saw each other at the gym and at various league functions plus going out after the gym for drinks. Jake is very easy going and easy to talk to, jokes a lot and I’m kinda the same but not as intense. He opened up about his marriage, his kids, his wife’s health issues, and later on, about their sex life and how it’s non existent because of her health issues and the kids etc. I opened up to Jake about dating struggles. Jake did ask me if I’m secretly gay or bi and I said no, he asked if I ever thought dudes like that and I did confide that I did find muscular dudes attractive to look at. I don’t know why. It wasn’t in a sexual way either. But that was it. This was back in late 2023.

Jake approached me after thanksgiving in 2024. He walked me to my car after a league game and told me he wanted to ask me something serious. We were alone (off to the corner of the lot) and Jake told me his wife doesn’t put out anymore. Their attempt to reignite their sex life got her pregnant and know she doesn’t want to sleep with him anymore because she doesn’t want a 7th kid. She feels bad and like she is neglecting him, so she gave him permission to find one trustworthy “fuck buddy” for him to have his needs met. This confused me for a minute until Jake admitted that he slept with a dude a few times before he got married back when he was 18-19. He enjoyed it and his wife knows about it. She said Jake can sleep with a guy but no women.

I couldn’t believe my fucking ears and I honestly was just stunned and looked like a lost idiot standing there. Jake then asked me if I would be willing to be his fuck buddy. I came to mind for him after what I said about muscular dudes and he said he finds me attractive and trustworthy. I declined immediately and told him I will never ever let another man fuck me in the ass.

Jake called me a dipshit and said “let me finish”, he explained that he wants me to fuck him in the ass. “I know you’ve fucked women in the ass. This is very similar but better.” I said I don’t know, I don’t know, and ummmmm and he said “just think about it seriously.”

That was on a Monday and by Wednesday I had already gotten curious and ventured into gay porn. I was gonna check it out but ended up spending 3 hours watching guys fuck each other.

Jake and I made plans to meet Saturday afternoon at his house, his basement. His wife is taking the kids to a birthday party for most of the afternoon.

I couldn’t believe I was gonna fuck another man but curiosity was eating away at me at this point and I went over to his place. He made me feel comfortable, offered me a drink, and then we went downstairs. I stood there like I was a virgin all over again as Jake took my clothes off and told me to stop being so nervous. Don’t overthink it. We were both soon naked, just like we had been many times in the locker room but now Jake was on a mission to get me to fuck him. He grabbed onto my cock and it was like a shockwave to have another dude touch me. I got hard in not time and Jake complimented me on 8” of dick and being uncut and said “this thing is gonna kill me. I haven’t been fucked in over a decade.”

He gave me a blowjob which was very hot and very nice. 5 minutes of this and Jake then got on his basement guest bed and laid on his stomach. His ass was really nice and bubbly, smooth and very much a married dad ass in appearance. He asked me to climb on top of him and to go slow. I followed his instructions and lined up after lubing up, slowly pushing against his tiny hole and feeling pressure and resistance. I eventually felt a pop and slowly started to sink in with Jake asking me to pause at times due to pain. I eventually sank into him and was laying on top of him. Jake gave me the green light to start slow and in no time, I was fucking him with slow and deep strokes. Jake started to moan and whimper and after a few minutes I scooted a bit up and continued to fuck and Jake yelled (scared the shit out of me) and said “right there right there right there don’t stop fuuuuuuccckkk” so I kept doing what I was doing. After a few minutes, I told Jake I was close and he told me to cum inside of him. Before I could do that, I felt his hole start to spasm and twitch and he said with a raspy voice that he is cumming. I followed suit a minute later and came as deep as I could inside him.

We laid like that for a minute before he told me to let him up and I slide out of him and rolled off of him. He laughed and smiled and said “fuck I forgot how good that feels”. He played with his hole a bit and said he can’t feel any cum leaking out and that it must be deep. He then mentioned “you definitely got me pregnant bro, fuck, my wife is gonna be pissed if my stomach starts to swell up haha”. It was the weirdest yet hottest thing I’ve ever heard.

20 minutes later we were fucking again, doggy style. Jake was talking to me more vocally now like he was my coach or something and telling me to “get it” and “there you go, right there, that’s what I’m talking about.”

It was belittling yet such a turn on.

I came inside him again and he yelled out “fuck yeah, breed me, breed that pussy.”

After the second round and some rest, Jake thanked me and said I should get going before his wife returns. She knows but doesn’t wanna know if that makes sense. I went home and surprisingly didn’t have post nut regret. I loved it.

Jake however didn’t end up with a happy ending to our fucking. Apparently he neglected to tell his wife that he “bottoms” when sleeping with a dude. She thought that he was on top but she never actually asked. She was angry when she found this bit out and lost her shit on Jake. She forbid him from sleeping with another dude afterwards and that was all there was to it. Jake and I still hang out and hoop like we used to and we talked about it once or twice after but never bring it up anymore.

I want to share this true story somewhere as I have no one to share it with. I also am deeply dying to try fucking a dudes ass again but can’t bring myself to try and find someone I trust. All I do for now is watch porn occasionally and sneak looks at the gym at bubbly asses I find attractive.