Hotel choice for Antigua

Me and my best friend (both 29F) are looking for a nice island vacation this summer and have decided on Antigua and narrowed it down to 3 hotels based on many things but mostly price reviews and all inclusives.

3 hotel options:

- St James Club

- Pineapple Beach

- Royalton

Our Island vacations usually entail us doing lots of water spots on the beach, drinking by the pool, and doing an excursion or 2 (hiking, snorkeling most likely). Any strong pros/cons to any of these options?

Thanks!